web analytics

CI rates Ice Cream Scoops

Zeroll Original Ice Cream Scoop

One of the most important pieces of kitchen equipment to have on hand during the summer – excluding a working refrigerator/freezer – is probablyt an ice cream scoop. That may be a big of an exaggeration, but when the weather is really hot, ice cream is a fantastic way to cool down quickly. A few months ago, Cook’s Illustrated ran a review of ice cream scoops to see which did the best job of delivering nice-looking scoops with the minimum of fuss.

They tested seven different brands for ease of use, comfort and appearance of the resulting ice cream scoop. They actually had to eliminate a lot of models based on the last category, either because the shape of the scoop was off or because the ice cream stuck so badly that there was little chance of getting a round scoop. Three brands emerged with high marks: the Rösle Ice Cream Scoop was the top finisher, easy to use and with camera-ready scoops, followed by the Zeroll Original Ice Cream Scoop (which I have and have always had great results with) and the Fantes Stainless Portion Scoop #16 (also known as a 1/4 cup scoop). The OXO i-Series Ice Cream Scoop and the KitchenAid Ice Cream Scoop were recommended with reservations, as the OXO made oblong scoops instead of round and the KitchenAid was very bulky. Not recommended were the Van Vacter Ice Cream Knife and the Tovolo Standz Ice Cream Scoop.

Although not inluded in the CI review, I still really like the ice cream scoop & stack from Cuisipro, which creates cylindrical “scoops” that are easy to pile into a cone. The shape of the ice cream has a little bit of a nostalgic feel for me, and it works qell after being dipped in hot water to ensure that the plunger will easily be able to push out the ice cream from the scoop.

Share this article

  • Cindy
    July 3, 2009

    We have an ice cream “spade” that I got from a friend a long time ago that works better than any scoop even though it doesn’t make round scoops.

  • Maggi
    July 4, 2009

    I have an ice cream scoop from (of all places) Tupperware. It’s a metal scoop like above, but the handle is covered in plastic. It is weighted well and I have always used it with great success with soft and rock hard ice cream alike. Nice round scoops too!

  • Michelle
    July 5, 2009

    Thanks so much for posting this review – I have horrible ice cream scoops! I added the Rosle scoop to my Amazon wish list 🙂

What do you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *