Easy Chocolate Fudge

Some men, for reasons I do not fully understand, insist on denouncing chocolate in all its forms. Perhaps they were once told that only women should love chocolate. I’m sure that this myth is founded on the (incorrect) assumption that all women will eat any kind of 5-cents-per-pound “chocolate” sold at the neighborhood drug store in boxes that look as though they’ve been around since the Eisenhower administration. Talk about insulting! Fortunately, even here in the states, general appreciation of quality chocolate is spreading like wildfire. Hopefully we’ll get this myth stamped out in short order. This myth is relevant here because I made this fudge for a friend who has, on occasion, espoused the belief that real men don’t eat chocolate. He does like fudge and brownies, though….

Fudge is a dense, creamy, semi-soft confection that melts in your mouth and is most often chocolate flavored. It has been around since the late 19th century. It’s origins, however, are shrouded in mystery. Some people attribute it to American college women using candy making as an excuse to stay up late. This sounds like a crazy theory to me. Doing homework? Studying? Valid reasons. Making candy? Delicious, sure, but perhaps not the best excuse.

However it came about, it is a popular treat. It can be made in a wide variety of flavors, ships well and tastes great. This fudge recipe must be one of the easiest there is. Based on this recipe, courtesy of Hersheys, I used different chocolate but followed the same procedure. The nice thing here is that you do not need a candy thermometer – just watch the clock when you’re cooking. It is important to stir constantly to prevent scorching your candy. It will start to set when you pour it into your pan, so just tap the bottom and sides a few times to smooth it out instead of trying to use a spatula or a knife to get a level top.

If you’re travelling with these, make sure to layer them with wax or parchment paper or they’ll stick together.

Easy Chocolate Fudge
1 1/2 cups sugar
5 oz. condensed milk
7 oz marshmallow fluff (1 jar)
4 tbsp butter, softened
12 oz chocolate (56% or semisweet), chopped
1 tsp vanilla
1/2 cup walnuts or pecans, chopped (optional)

Line a 8×8 inch baking pan with foil or plastic wrap and butter it.
In a medium sauce pan, combine sugar, milk, marshmallow and butter. Bring mixture to a boil, stirring often. Continue to cook over medium heat for 5 minutes, stirring constantly. Use a heat resistant spatula to scrape down the sides of the pan.
Remove from heat and stir in chocolate and vanilla until mixture is smooth. Pour immediately into prepared pan. Let set for 1 hour in the refrigerator before slicing.
Store in an airtight container in the fridge.
Makes 3 dozen squares.

Substitution notes: If you cannot get evaporated milk/unsweetened condensed milk, use half and half or light cream. If you cannot get a jar of marshmallow fluff, use 1- 10 oz bag of marshmallows.
Let me also take this opportunity to note not to use store bought Australian marshmallows as a substitute unless you can get jet puffed ones. I never saw American-style marshmallows when I was in Aus., but the ones I usually snacked on were chewy/crumbly and dry (I liked them, though!) and would not be appropriate for this recipe. It needs to be creamy. I’m sure it would work with homemade marshmallow fluff, though…


  1. those look VERY inviting. chocolate is my best friend and I think it should be a staple food. haha. those who avoid chocolates are definitely missing out on something big.

  2. Thanks, I think they look inviting, too. Who could resist such a neat and tasty package? Not that I’m tooting my own horn here. =)

  3. I’ve been reading the Hannah Swenson mysteries, and in any crisis, Hannah recommends chocolate!

    That fudge looks wonderful, but alas!, I grew up in a drop-fudge house. I was raised watching my Grammy stir for ages, then beat the goey mixture on platters for ever. And now, of course, I have to make it the same way!
    I can admire, from afar, pan fudge…but my family’s honor won’t allow me to taste!

  4. Never tried to make fudge before. Have a good excuse now.
    I like the way you neatly packed them to avoid sticking.

  5. Stephanie – I have to say that you’re lucky because most people don’t make fudge like that anymore. And I can’t say I blame you for preferring it your grandmother’s way!

    Dreska- Thanks. With fudge, you have to take the time to make the packaging well so they don’t all stick together.

  6. Your post makes me think of my dad. On a wintery afternoon he would pull out the can of Hershey’s Cocoa and make fudge. Actually the same memory (same recipe?) as Stephanie! It took forever and us kids were always impatient!

  7. Hello Nic.
    I really really really enjoyed reading your blog!!! i discovered your blog and i stayed on it for about 1,5 hour!!! Reading all your recipes. Wow. I wished i had an oven in my studentdorm… Might go to a friend tomorrow to bake in her oven… Can’t wait to try your recipes!! I added your site to my favorites, so that says a lot!!! Thank you sooo much Nic. You made my day.

  8. This fudge looks really creamy. I never made fudge, but I’ve tasted it and do not like to feel the texture of the granulated sugar in my mouth.

    They look beautiful though.

  9. Melissa – Food memories are the best, I think.

    Corianne – You made my day, too.

    Ana – I know exactly what you’re refering to. I think this fudge is pretty creamy, but it definately has a touch of the granular, melt-in-your mouth touch typical of fudge.

  10. Hi Nic
    these look great… pity about the Aussie marshmallows….

    But I just posted the AQIS rules…
    I hope it helps

  11. Wow! That’s yummy looking fudge. I’m usually not a big fan of fudge, but a piece of that would be welcomed right now. I might just have to give that one a try.

  12. I keep meaning to write you a note to let you know how much I enjoy your blog. Congratulations on finishing your classes. I’ve been using your recipes and I love them!

  13. Clare – Thanks for posting it. I’ll probably make an announcement for the mini-event after SHF.

    Liz – If you do try it, I hope that you enjoy it. It’s darn good fudge.

    Lauren – Thank you!

  14. Banyan Productions, (the producers of Trading Spaces, Epicurious, Birth Day, and Ambush Makeover), just released a new video that has a ton of great recipes that you can get to the table in 15 minutes or less. They’ve got some of them running on Comcast’s On Demand service (which is how I found out about it) and have a 2 DVD set that you can buy. Here’s a link to their website with more info http://www.15andDone.com

  15. Oh, Nic- if only I’d used this recipe at Christmas instead of James Beard’s ‘Never Fail Fudge’, which failed so spectacularly that I couldn’t (wouldn’t) give any of it away. I threw it in the freezer (all 4 1/2 pounds of it!) and planned on using it as a ganache, but picked at it when I had cravings instead. I just got rid of the last 3 lbs. a couple of weeks ago…what a disaster.

    Your shots are looking great!

  16. Dang, that looks too good! We should start coding posts, to warn readers about what they are about to get sucked into… Danger: Sugar Alert Ahead!

    I had fun last halloween making odd ball fudge. Substituting white chocolate works well in this recipe, which then screams for the addition of neon food coloring, and cool flavors! Orange, lime, and blue mint worked great. :)

    thanks for the memory

  17. Moria – Sometimes we just have to let go of the results of less-than-successful attempts. It’s a shame when it’s fudge, though.

    McAuliflower – Blue Mint? Wow. I bet the kids loved that!

  18. Looks good.

    Do You have the recipe for the ‘Hard to make fudge’ like what Stephanie and Melissa spoke about ? Just want to give that also a shot

  19. Hello Nic,

    I’m residing in Singapore. I’d like to try this recipe but the problem is I can’t find Marshmallow Fluff or Creme anywhere here. How can I turn Marshmallow into Fluff?
    Your kind advice is greatly appreciated! :)))


  20. must be heaven…yummy!


  21. Will make a mental note of this recipe using Fluff as well! Thanks, Nic!

  22. I haven’t made this in more than a decade, but somehow I’m craving it now like crazy! Thanks for pointing us to your recipe – I may just have to give it a try! (by the way, have you ever had success with fudge made ‘the real way’?)

  23. I haven’t made fudge the old fashioned way in a long time. But the holidays are approaching (distantly, but steadily), so perhaps I’ll get one out to give as gifts.

  24. I recently made a batch of the easy chocolate fudge, but with a few ammendments: I replaced the butter with peanut butter and cut the recipe in half then chilled it in a tiny bread pan. Turned out just great!! Even my partner’s English family that usually scoffs at the idea of combining peanut butter with either chocolate or jam loved it!!! Thanks for the recipe.

  25. I can’t wait to try this recipe! It looks delicious! Thanks for posting it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Scroll To Top