Everyday Food rates Gluten Free Baking Mixes

Everyday Food rates Gluten Free Baking Mixes
Gluten free baking is easier than it has ever been before. Just a few short years ago, gluten free ingredients were difficult to find and the results that you would get when working on a recipe could be unpredictable, to say the least. These days, there are a wide range of gluten free flours and baking mixes that are available at most markets and they have helped to raise the bar of gluten free baking, both for the quality of the products you can make and for how easy it is do to it.

There are many to choose from and not all gluten free baking mixes are created equal. Some work better for certain types of baked goods than others. In a recent issue, Everyday Food tested and compared several brands of gluten free flour mixes to see how they performed. Their findings definitely proved that some mixes are better for certain things than others.

  • C4C Gluten Free Flour – Overall favorite. This mix was developed at The French Laundry and produced light and fluffy cakes consistently and was good for all types of baking.
  • Gluten Free Pantry All Purpose Flour – Good for cakes. This flour had a very mild taste, but could impart a slightly grainy texture to baked goods. Chocolate chip cookies were slightly dry.
  • Hodgson Mill Multi-Purpose Baking Mix - Favorite whole grain. Chocolate chip cookies had a great texture and added 3 grams of fiber per quarter cup.
  • King Arthur Multi-Purpose Gluten Free Flour - Good for muffins. This mix produced hard, sandy cookies but worked well in very moist baked goods, like muffins and banana breads.
  • Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free All Purpose Flour – Good for savory dishes. This bean-based flour had a flavor that didn’t mesh well with some sweeter baked goods, though they had a good texture.

In my own experiences with gluten free baking mixes, I would definitely encourage you to do some experimentation. For instance, I did not have good results with the King Arthur mix in my Gluten Free Thin Mints, but had excellent results with Bob’s Red Mill and C4C. These are helpful guidelines, but nothing beats trying a few and seeing which ones produce the best results in your own baked goods.

5 comments

  1. My boyfriend and I recently went gluten free due to an intolerance he inherited from his father and I’ve tried a bunch of different gluten free flours. My favorite, at this point, is Jules Gluten Free Flour (you can google it to find her stuff). It’s just pretty darn expensive, but I can substitute it 1:1 in most recipes I’ve tried!

  2. My adult daughter has multiple food issues – gluten is just one of them. All of the flours you mentioned have something she is not able to eat – potato flour, milk, corn starch, etc. The best we’ve found so far is the Namaste Foods, Gluten Free Perfect Flour Blend. I haven’t tried it for everything but it made great pumpkin and banana bread at Thanksgiving and wonderful pancakes over the weekend. I substituted it 1:1 when making the quick breads.

  3. Thanks for this list! I agree that C4C is the best one I’ve tried so far. I’ll stick to what works!

  4. I bake for my sister-in-law how has Celiac. After years of testing several gluten free flours I preferred King Arthur. It works well in cakes, and gets least complains of strange after tastes.

  5. I have been gluten free since 1999 and I’ve tried many different flour blends. I tried Sugar & Spice Market Gluten Free All Purpose flour and it tastes and bakes great in my recipes. So now it is what I use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Scroll To Top