Cook’s Illustrated picks the best nonstick pans

T Fal and Bialetti Frying PAns

I know that I’m not the only one who has gone through multiple nonstick frying pans over the years, replacing the pans as they lose their nonstickiness or treating them like regular pans and simply increasing the amount of oil that I cook with to keep food from sticking to it. I generally assumed that I was doing something wrong with my pans to mess up their nonstick coatings over time. But Cook’s Illustrated tackled nonstick pans in a recent issue (Sept/Oct 2010) and revealed that nonstick pans aren’t made to last a lifetime. Far from it. In fact, even representatives from the Cookware Manufacturers Association acknowledge that “if you get a year to a year and a half of life out of [a new nonstick pan], [they] think you got a pretty good deal.” High heat, cooking sprays, cleaners and kitchen tools can all wear down that coating over time. How quickly the coating wears down depends on how the coating was applied and how the pan was constructed.

This begs the question, are any nonstick pans better than the rest? Which brands hold up over time and give you a nonstick surface longer than others? Cook’s Illustrated set out to test a number of relatively inexpensive nonstick pans and compared them to their previous favorite, a $159 All Clad pan.

The first test of the skillet showdown was the most revealing. CI began frying eggs without fat in each pan. Some pans began to stick after just two eggs (Farberware’s Premium Nonstick Shallow 12-in Skillet), while others lasted for 76+ fried eggs (T-Fal Professional Total Nonstick 12.5-inch Fry Pan and Bialetti Commercial 12-in Saute Pan), at which point the test was ended because those two pans so dramatically outperformed the competition. After the eggs, stir fries were cooked to test the pans’ ability to deal with high heat and crepes were cooked to test for hot spots. The pans were also banged on the countertop, exposed to metal cooking utensils and tossed in the dishwasher to test durability.

The winner by a long shot was the T-Fal Professional Total Nonstick 12.5-inch Fry Pan. Not only did its 5-layer nonstick coating remain nonsticky through the end of the test, but it was hardly marked by a sharp knife cutting things on its surface and consistently provided even heat. The handle came slightly loose after being banged on a countertop repeatedly, but at only $34.95, this pan clearly provided a great value. CI’s previous favorite, the $159 All Clad nonstick didn’t even preform quite as well, with its nonstick coating losing a little of its slickness after all that abuse, although since the All Clad comes with a lifetime replacement guarantee (despite costing as much as 4 T-Fal pans) it still was ranked right up there with the T-Fal as a top nonstick by Cook’s Illustrated.

8 comments

  1. I hope you get some sort of affiliate $ cuz I am buying this right now! You were the 2nd post I read this morning about fry pans for some reason, and they other was way way expensive. I’ve paid this much for one I now totally hate as it is wrecked :) Just in case you care :)

  2. Glad to know I’m not the only one who has to replace their skillet every couple of years – I do use mine almost daily and don’t put it in the dishwasher. I’ve used and loved T-Fal pans for years, although I don’t think they’ve been from the professional line. I need a new pan soon and will look for this one.

  3. I have had the T-fal for 4 years now, and the handles are starting to rust and get loose. I do agree about the non-stick part, my husband has made a many an egg in these and left it to sit for 2 hours until I can get to it and the stuff just wipes clean no problem. So, yes good bang for your buck if you don’t mind replacing them when the handles go bad.

  4. Does anyone know where to get this model T-Fal frypan at? It doesn’t seem to be available anywhere online. Thanks!

  5. I read recently:
    DuPont and 3M were among companies that agreed to eliminate perfluorooctanoic acid, or PFOA, from products including Teflon by 2015 amid government and consumer concern that the chemical may harm people. DuPont has said PFOA has mostly been removed from products introduced since 2007, while 3M said it completed the phase-out of last year.

    So what’s a safe alternative? Has Cook’s reviewed safer pans? Dupont has a new aqueous Teflon coatings? Don’t know why its safer.

  6. This is a great summary – thanks for posting.

  7. Thanks for this post! I love using a non-stick pan but hate how they don’t last. Count me in as someone who was researching a good one and found this. I’m ordering mine right now along with some good non-scratching cooking utensils to use in it.

  8. Frederick B Campbell

    Please learn how to spell the word “lose.” (Take comfort in the fact you’re not the only one). And I want to thank you for summarizing the review. I just bought the T-Fal pan.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Scroll To Top